Sunday, June 7, 2009

Lemon Sandwich Cookies

Cookies for a friend.






















This past weekend one of my closet friends from back home, Lindsay, flew to DC for her cousin's graduation. Lindsay just so happens to be the same friend who designed my logo and business cards. She is quite the talented graphic designer. Lindsay is one of those friends who would do anything for me. When she told me she was coming to town for her cousin's wedding we made arrangements so she could come to town early and spend some time with me. I wanted to bake something special just for her, so I had her send me a list things she liked and disliked in her desserts. This is the list she sent me:

Hate:
1. Coconut
2. Cream cheese icing

Not crazy about:
1. Nuts

Like:
1. Stuff with fruit or jam
2. Buttercream frosting
3. Sprinkles
4. Pumpkin

I pulled inspiration from cookies I had seen on The Crepes of Wrath and My Baking Addiction to make Lemon Sandwich Cookies. I was pretty impressed with myself getting three of her "likes" in one cookie. These cookies tasted great! I was not sure how I would feel about them since I am typically not a fruit dessert person, but I loved them and so did Lindsay and my boyfriend. In addition to being really cute, these cookies were a really nice change from chocolate chip cookies. You can change the cookie and frosting combinations to match your favorite flavors. I am thinking about making these again with a chocolate cookie and peanut butter frosting.

Lemon Sandwich Cookies
Inspired by The Crepes of Wrath and My Baking Addiction

Cookies

1 (18.25) package lemon cake mix
2 eggs
1/3 cup vegetable oil
2 teaspoons lemon zest
4 TBS fresh lemon juice
1/4 - 1/2 cup all purpose flour

Preheat oven to 375 degrees F (190 degrees C). Pour cake mix into a large bowl. Stir in eggs, oils, lemon juice, and lemon zest until blended. If mixture is very wet slowly add 1/4 to 1/2 cup of flour until the dough comes together.

Drop teaspoons of dough onto an ungreased cookie sheet. Bake 7-9 minutes in the preheated oven. The bottoms will be light brown. Move cookies to a cooling rack and using your spatula gently flatten your cookies.

Buttercream Frosting

3 cups powdered sugar
3/4 cup butter, softened
zest of one lemon
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2-3 tablespoons lemon juice

1. Cream sugar, butter, lemon zest, and vanilla. Add 2 tablespoons of lemon juice and beat until fluffy, adding more if needed.

Assembly:

Frost the flat side of the cookie with a good dollop of frosting. Lightly place the flat side of an unfrosted cookie on top. Press down until a bit of the frosting begins to poke out of the sides. If you want to decorate the edges, place your sprinkles/chips/etc. in a small bowl, and dip the sides of the cookie in it, rolling the cookie around to coat all sides.

Stumble Upon Toolbar

37 comments:

Steph said...

I wish my friends would back cookies for me! :) I love those sprinkles!

Maria said...

What a fun cookie! Your friends are lucky!

Sara said...

Yum! They look great and so cute!

Cari said...

Yummy Risa!

pookiepantry said...

i made these once, only with chocolate cake mix instead... they were amazing and yours look like they were too!

Melody said...

I made the chocolate ones tonight and my son said that I'm the best "cooker" ever. Next time I need to give lemon a try. Who doesn't love sprinkles!

Bunny said...

I love lemon so these are perfect for me, they looks so soft!!

apparentlyjessy said...

Oh Risa, what a sweet friend you are! These cookies are just so cute! I love lemon and I love the sprinkles on them. I will have to give these a try someday, well ad them to my list of things to try anyway! hehe

cookies and cups said...

Love anything with sprinkles and these sound delicious!

Jessica said...

Those cookies are seriously adorable. Sandwich cookies are great but sandwich cookies with sprinkles? Best ever.

Ingrid said...

I probably say this all the tim but I wish I wasn't so lazy about making cookies. Yours look like they would be winners with the kids.
~ingrid

finsmom said...

Could these be any cuter looking?!? Love them! I just might be making these for my daughters preschool party :)

♥peachkins♥ said...

I love lemons and your cookies looks great!

Liesl said...

Sounds like an easy go to recipe!! I bet your friend was so excited!!! I have a secret addiction to peanut butter so I may have to try something like this (like you said) with peanut butter frosting! YUM!

Katrina said...

I love taking a break from chocolate now and then and these look like the perfect way to do it! (Course, I'll always come back to chocolate, but I like the break!) ;)
Love the sprinkles!

Holly. said...

Mmm..I'm with you on the whole fruit/dessert thing, but these look really good.

Leslie said...

what a great friend and what yummy cookies you baked for her

The Cooking Photographer said...

Hi Risa,

Omgosh what's not to love here?? Lemon cookies, frosting and sprinklesssss!

These cookies make me happy to just look at them.

Laura

Juliana said...

Such a nice friend you are...I like the idea of using cake mix for the dough...look so colorful and tasty. Yummie!

Karine said...

Your cookies look amazing! And I love the picture!

anudivya said...

Aww, that looks adorable. I love the ring of sprinkles on the sides. Spells fun to me.

Grace said...

ha--her hates are my loves! regardless, i like what you made for her--the sprinkles really are a lovely touch. :)

Avanika [YumsiliciousBakes] said...

These cookies are adorable! I love how cute you made them with the addition of sprinkles :D

I've given you an award : http://yumsiliciousbakes.blogspot.com/2009/06/my-first-award-d.html

Melinda said...

Gorgeous cookies!

Lynn said...

Now if only my mouth would stop watering long enough for my brain to think of other words besides 'Mmmm....cookie'. I have added you to my Google Reader (which I knew nothing about having until today after using Blogger Dashboard for ages). I will now stalk your food ways.

My best, Lynn :o)
*tea giveaway this week, stop on by...

Jamie said...

These look amazing! Your friend is lucky!

Culinary Cory said...

For some reason, I've been craving lemon a lot lately. These cookies look wonderful. I love the colored sprinkles. Such a cute touch.

burpandslurp said...

Can I be your friend? lol.
Your friend is blessed to have a thoughtful, amazing baker like you!

RecipeGirl said...

These are darling! HATE cream cheese icing? What kind of friend is that? (just kiddin', of course... I love the stuff :) )

Mermaid Sweets said...

Those cookies look fabulous, so delicious and fun.

Jennifer said...

FUN, sweet and YUMMY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

CookiePie said...

What pretty cookies -- you're a good friend!

Anonymous said...

A few months ago I was trying to find a lemon cookie recipe like the Girl Scout cookie, because my daughter loved them. This is how I found your website... with the Samoas cookies/bars. I have been following ever since. This is the recipe (minus the buttercream frosting and sprinkles, but with a lemon glaze) I used. She sold them at a garage sale and had huge success! You have a fabulous talent and I have enjoyed reading your ideas and trying a few of them!

Risa said...

I just wanted to thank everybody for the nice comments. I agree with the last comment that these cookies taste just like the lemon girl scout cookies.

Ashlee said...

Im gonna try this but maybe w/ like a vanilla cake mix instead

Stephanie said...

Oooh YUM... and they're so CUTE!!!

Carrie said...

Wow those look yummy!