Sunday, April 26, 2009

Cookie Dough Pops

Take a closer look.


















At first glance these may look like your typical cake pop made famous by Bakerella, but once you take your first bite you will realize these are not cake pops. Here take another look.
























Yep, that is chocolate chip cookie dough in that pop (don't worry, there are no raw eggs). I was talking with Elyse, of the wonderful Elyse's Confectionery Creations, and she and I were wondering what we can make to be the next big thing. We have lofty dreams of opening a bakery together one day so we needed something to get us the much needed exposure. Something that had not been done before (or at least that we had not known had been done, I apologize for taking credit if you made these first) and would appeal to the masses. We came up with a few ideas, and although they seemed good, they were not exactly what we were looking for. I am not sure how this idea popped in my head, but I must have been thinking about Bakerella's cake pops. I have made cake pops and brownie pops, but had anybody made cookie pops? When I mentioned it to Elyse she was confident this was what we needed to make. We discussed technique and flavors. In the end we decided chocolate chip would be perfect since it is traditional. Then the next day Elyse came up with the great idea to also make a S'mores Cookie dough pop. So this Sunday Elyse and I baked together from either end of the country. She being in Berkeley and me being in Washington, DC, connected by Gchat.

I found these pops to be extremely delicious and simple to make. You don't have to bake anything so it is a perfect recipe when it is too hot to use the oven. Any cookie recipe will work you just need to tweek it a little to adjust for not using eggs. I hope these catch on like the cake pops have. Now when you finish here make sure to check Elyse's post.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pops
pictured above

1 cup all purpose flour
1/4 tsp salt
dash of cinnamon
1 stick butter, softened (it is even okay if it is melting a little)
1/2 cup brown sugar
1/4 cup sugar
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
3/4 cups mini semi-sweet chocolate chips

Assorted candy melts:
1/2 package white chocolate candy melts
1/2 package chocolate candy melts
1/4 cup light blue candy melts

In a medium bowl combine the flour, salt, and dash of cinnamon. In a second larger bowl, beat together the butter, sugar, brown sugar, and vanilla extract until creamy. Slowly beat in the flour mixture until smooth. Stir in the chocolate chips. Roll the mixture into quarter size balls and lay on cookie sheet lined with wax paper (Should make approximately 20) and insert a lolly pop stick. Chill for several hours or freeze for 15-20 minutes until firm.

Melt candy melts in the microwave per directions on package. (30 sec intervals, stirring in between.) Gently dip the cookie dough ball into the candy coating by holding the lollipop stick and rotating until covered (if your lolly pop stick falls out, just dip the end in the melted chocolate and put it back in the ball). Once covered remove and softly tap and rotate until the excess chocolate falls off. Place in a styrofoam block to dry.

To decorate with drizzled chocolate, place chocolate in a sandwich bag on a microwave safe dish and microwave in 30 second intervals moving the chocolate around between. Using scissors, cut the very tip off the sandwich bag. The smaller your cut, the smaller the drizzle. Use the sandwich bag to pipe the chocolate back and forth over the cookie dough pop until you reach the desired look. Return to styrofoam block to dry.

S'mores Cookie Dough Pops
pictured below

1/2 cup all purpose flour
3/4 cup graham cracker crumbs, divided
1/4 tsp salt
dash of cinnamon
1 stick butter, softened (it is even okay if it is melting a little)
1/2 cup brown sugar
1/4 cup sugar
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
3/4 cup chopped Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar
3/4 cup mini-marshmallows, halved

Assorted candy melts:
1/2 package white chocolate candy melts
1/2 package chocolate candy melts

In a medium bowl combine the flour, 1/2 cup graham cracker crumbs, salt, and dash of cinnamon. In a second larger bowl, beat together the butter, sugar, brown sugar and vanilla extract until creamy. Slowly beat in the flour mixture until smooth. Stir in the chocolate and marshmallows. Roll the mixture into quarter size balls and lay on cookie sheet lined with wax paper (Should make approximately 20) and insert a lolly pop stick. Chill for several hours or freeze for 15-20 minutes until firm.

Melt candy melts in the microwave per directions on package. (30 sec intervals, stirring in between.) Gently dip the cookie dough ball into the candy coating by holding the lollipop stick and rotating until covered (if your lolly pop stick falls out, just dip the end in the melted chocolate and put it back in the ball). Once covered remove and softly tap and rotate until the excess chocolate falls off. Sprinkle with remaining graham cracker crumbs. Place in a styrofoam block to dry.

58 comments:

Eliana said...

You are so on to something here. I haven't seen these either and am now sitting here asking myself how come I didn't think of it!

Maria said...

Fabulos pops! Can I join you two in your bakery adventure?:)

teresa said...

I had to come by after such rave reviews from Elyse. These are so much fun, and so cute! I can't wait to try them.

jenn@slim-shoppin said...

I have never seen these before either!

Great idea, and I hope you guys do open a bakery one day, how fun would that be?

Bunny said...

These are absolutely adorable!! I saw them on Elyse's blog too!!

Ingrid said...

Oh, I love you guys! Those look amazing! How'd the s'mores ones taste? Good?! I'm printing out the recipe! :)
~ingrid

Sharon said...

Awh, those look so cute and tasty!

Joslyn said...

Do you store them in the fridge?

Katrina said...

Amazingly delicious! Way to go, Girls! There are cookie dough truffles, but how awesome to put them on a stick. (I also like the sounds of your recipe better!) Your pops look darling and delicious! I often feel that I like cookie dough more than a cookie. Sigh.

Mermaid Sweets said...

Wow, you guys really came up with something special. I want in on the bakery! I will definately have to try these soon. Thanks you baking dynamo.

Sara said...

Great idea!! I totally have a bakery dream too. :) I'd definately come to your bakery and buy these cookie dough pops.

apparentlyjessy said...

I came across your blog whilst blog surfing and I really love your style! I think you are onto something here with the cookie dough pops, they look delicious!

I also love the the home made girl scout cookies, I am definitely going to give those a try!

So I'm going to follow you and look forward to seeing what you come up with next :D

Elyse said...

This was sooo much fun, Risa!! Yay for our baking session. Once these pops become big hits, our lofty dreams of the bakery won't be so "lofty", right? Hope you're getting a good night's sleep right now. I'll talk to you tomorrow!

Jennifer said...

All I can say is STUNNING and yum!!!!

Cookie baker Lynn said...

Those look wonderful! I especially like the darling bows on them. Too cute!

Justin Schwartz said...

these look fantastic

oneordinaryday said...

I still haven't tried brownie pops and now I'm going to have to add s'mores pops to my list. I did a choc. chip cookie dough truffle for xmas but mine used sweetened condensed milk and it was just too sweet. I'm going to have to give your recipe a try. They look amazing.
Michelle

The Italian Dish said...

Wow! I've been making the Bakerella cake pops, but my boys would LOVE these, with the chocolate chip cookie dough. I've bookmarked this recipe. Great idea!

finsmom said...

These are so cute! I love the ribbons!

Trixy said...

They look so delicious and divine! (:

Marie said...

An absolutely brilliant idea, they look great and how clever to omit the eggs for food safety!

Rose said...

Wow, they look really good. I have never seen or heard of any pops like these or the cake ones here in Australia, but they look delicious :)

burpandslurp said...

how sweet! they actually look perfectly harmless and tempting!

Hayley said...

These are awesome! Cookie dough is my favorite, I can't wait to make these at my next party. Thanks for sharing!

Shanbanan said...

I've wondered about something like this before. Since I don't really like cake, the cake pops don't really appeal to me. I'm wondering if these would need to be refrigerated because of the butter if you need to make them ahead? What does everyone think?

I personally would love a Snickerdoodle pop, but I can't figure what kind of candy melt to use. All that's coming to mind is to go with a cinnamon chip that's been melted? Any other suggestions?

Risa said...

I have been storing them in the fridge and I recommend serving them chilled. So if you make them for a party, just keep them in the fridge until party time.

For a snickerdoodle pop I would use the traditional snickerdoodle cookie dough, but mix the cinnamon in sugar into the dough. I would dip it in white chocolate and perhaps sprinkle it with more cinnamon and sugar.

Thanks for all the comments!

Annie said...

How creative... I came over from Elyse's blog and she was right about your treats. Your pops are absolutely gorgeous!!!

Tammy said...

This is an awesome idea, and I hope it makes the impact you hope for. It looks perfect in every way! How special it is to have a friend to share grand cooking dreams with.

Leslie said...

Oh my..I am in love w/ raw cookie dough! I have never thought of using no eggs. Smart! these are darling!!!

Hi! I'm Kirsten... said...

Yum!!!!! Definitely want to make these for my next party!!

Bethany said...

Wow, love your pics and the idea is fabulous!

Dawn said...

I do love these and I love Elyse just as much.
But I have to say I adore that blue and brown polka dot ribbon. It's funny how us girls notice those things? Great post!

Liesl said...

mmmm those look and sound delicious! I love anything smore's!

Culinary Cory said...

These pops look amazing! I love how the bold blues contrast will against the dark browns. They look like spring!

5 Star Foodie said...

These cookie pops are awesome! Love the sweets on your site. I also live in Washington DC area (NoVa part)

dessertobsessed said...

these are so amazing and pretty! you should definitely open a bake shop!

Nick said...

My gosh, these look fantastic. I've been meaning to work on a raw peanut butter cookie dough...

EllaAfter said...

Two thumbs up!

cookies and cups said...

These look great! I was thinking of doing something similar, but thought about doing it with already made cookies instead of cookie dough. I bet they tasted delicious!!! I will for sure give them a try!

Kerry said...

I don't know how you made your's so pretty!! I made these this morning and they are DELICIOUS! One question though (if you have any suggestions!) - how did you keep your cookie dough balls from getting flat on one side? That was my main problem :)

Awesome recipe! Thank you!

Melissa said...

Helloooo!!!!! I feel like Im in Heaven right now after finding your blog! But one question on these cookie dough pops.. is it white chocolate with blue coloring that is drizzled on top? I love how they match the ribbon!

Risa said...

Hi Melissa,

I dipped half the pops in white chocolate. The blue drizzle is actually blue candy melts that I bought from the craft store. I did not have to color them or anything which made these even easier.

Martha said...

How adorable! Cookie Dough Pops may be the next big trend :-)

Alana said...

What a fantastic idea! I've been looking for recipes for "treat" pops, and these look phenominal! I can't wait to try this recipe tonight!

Vashti said...

i would love to see the inside of one of the smores ones. they all look and sound yummy.

HLEure said...

You are a genius. I've been wanting to make cake pops or cupcake pops for ages, but I don't have anyone to make them for, and I don't think the husband would be that impressed. Too much "cute factor" for him. But...he LOVES cookie dough. I think his love for the fabulousness that is cookie dough would overshadow his skepticism based merely on their adorableness. That said, I'm making these this weekend while he's out of town to surprise him when he gets back. Thanks so much for the inspiration!

Hilary said...

I, too, LOVE cake balls and I think you're right, these may be the next big thing. They look delicious. Can't wait to try them!

drippingwithdesserts.blogspot.com

Mashuga Mom said...

Yummy! These look amazingly delicious. I will definately need to try them & get my toddler to help dip them. How amazing- Great & creative idea. thanks-
MashugaMom
www.MashugaMom.com

Harmony said...

I've had these bookmarked for quite a while, and decided to make a mint version. used your cookie dough recipe above, but used mint extract instead of vanilla, added some cocoa powder, and used mint chips.Fabulous!

徵信社 said...

so beautiful!I love it! Very creative!That's actually really cool.
謝謝你的文章分享,請你有空到我

參觀,Thanks

Brenda said...

I just made the cookie dough pops, but as truffles to give as a gift. There were awesome. I used almond bark instead of candy melts, works just fine. I also think that I would make it without any cinnamon next time. The flavor is so perfect, I might make a batch of the cookie dough just to eat. Thanks for the great idea, I can't wait to try the peanut butter, smores and oreo ones.

Shami said...

Uh... wow! Cookie Dough Pops? They sound delightful and I can't wait to try both recipes. Thank you for your creative genius in the kitchen. It's really quite inspiring... and tasty :)

Mel said...

I made these for a Jack and Jill shower last weekend. They were easy and fantastic. Thanks for the great recipe.

Tracey @ Kitchen Playground said...

Just made (& posted about) these in truffle form ... without the stick, that is. Thank you so much for recipe and inspiration!

Mrs4444 said...

Wow! Great idea! :)

Anonymous said...

Great idea, just made them as a tester before I do them for my cafe. Hoping to roll and do cut outs, then dip/decorate for christmas treats. Thank you!

Natalie said...

These sound delicious! I am not a big fan of cake so cake pops aren't my thing, but cookie dough is a different story! Treats on a stick are the best. I just made some cookie pops for my blog and they turned out pretty cute. Thanks for the tutorial!

Cheers,
Natalie

SScotty said...

This recipe is fantastic! I just made some in a heart shape for my boyfriend this coming valentines day! I wrapped them in cellophane and tied it round the stick with a red ribbon :) Thanks for this! He will love it x